• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Welcome to Fat Sully's Pizza

Nestled in Kansas City, MO, Fat Sully's Pizza has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Renowned for its mouthwatering New York-style pizzas, generous portion sizes, and diverse toppings selection, this pizzeria offers an unforgettable dining experience. Customers rave about the fresh and tasty parmesan garlic wings, gigantic slices of pizza, and impeccable service. The vibrant atmosphere, complete with big screens and a full bar, makes it perfect for casual outings with friends or family. Whether you're a pizza enthusiast or craving classic comfort food, Fat Sully's Pizza is a must-visit destination that promises satisfaction with every bite.

Fat Sully's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Aaron M.
Aaron M.

Food was delicious, wings and pizza were both top notch. Restaurant had big screens with sports on, and was an enjoyable dinner with our kids. Definitely recommend!

Yesenia M.
Yesenia M.

Amazing joint for the classics! I ordered the slice of pizza (beware it it huge) and parmesan garlic wings and both tasted so fresh and tasty! Service was awesome. Atmosphere is perfect for late night casual outing with friends or even a date night as there is a bar and some table games available. I really enjoyed my food, glad to have discovered this spot!

Mellinda L.
Mellinda L.

Best Pizza in Missouri!! Hands down the best. We were visiting Kansas City for five days and we ate at this restaurant 3 1/2 of the five days. It was that delicious incredible. The customer service was excellent and the ambience with all the glass windows and rollup garage doors made you feel like you're sitting outside. The pizzas were all incredible. Love that you got to pick your own toppings. BEST Pizza, Missouri

Raul Z.
Raul Z.

We were in KC visiting friends and family. We meet up with Jason and Emily for a brunch. What a great choice to have brunch. When we got there J and E were wait outside for us. We waited for about 20-30 minutes before we sat down. The weather was super nice at that time. We aren't used to cold weather, but it was nice that time of day. The parking is mostly street parking. They have a really small parking area, but there is plenty of room inside. Restaurant is super nice inside, a full bar and plenty of beer on tap and liquor. It was also brunch time, so they had mimosas.i got me a Pabst Blue Ribbon, just cause I've never had one on tap. It was great. Maria asked for coffee, they said it was self serve, so Maria said she's on vacation and didn't get coffee, my wife is silly. Our waiter had a great sense of humor and made our time there great. Once we got to our table, I noticed that my seat and the floor was dirty. This is the only knock on this place. I just wiped down the seat and sat down. I had the Nashville hot chicken biscuit, wow. It was juicy and not too spicy. I was one the fence on what to try so I just went with this one. Maria had the Lola, which was chicken in a biscuit with bacon and covered in maple syrup. This is more my speed, but I was worried about the syrup and chicken combo. I don't know why, I like sweet and salty. Maria made a great choice. J had a smash burger. He said it was great. E had biscuits and gravy, bacon and hash browns. It all looked great. I normally eat off every one plate, but this was our first meeting and I didn't want to come of as a pig. lol Made it to the bathrooms, and they were clean. I look forward to going back here as soon as possible.

Harry P.
Harry P.

Best hamburger in town bar none!! And Denver biscuit co in the morning is outstanding as well ! I'm not a big pizza eater but I've seen a lot of them come out of the kitchen and looks fantastic and I bet the large pizza could replace a tire on a semi truck!!!! Oh and the waffle fries with mushroom gravy !! Fantastic!!!

Todd K.
Todd K.

Very good New York style pizza. Pepperoni and extra cheese this time. Only complaint is that it arrived cold, but probably due to the distance it had to be delivered. If it were hot, I'll bet it would have been even better. Also, the pizzas are huge. Caesar salad was better than most as well for a pizza place.

Graham L.
Graham L.

Food - good for NY style pizza and they have a late night window too on 80th for quick drive in/by orders. Service - good Ambiance - big spacious place with a good size bar to sit at. Pizza/Burgers/Biscuit sandwiches (till 2pm) all in the same place! Had the single smash the other day - tasty Tried a MYO slice today, Pepperoni, Garlic, Mushrooms. A big 'u sure u can handle this?' Slice of very thin crust NY style pizza. Tascio's and Buffalo State may have some competition here. If you don't order cheese on the slice, then there may not be any on it. Good taste with a healthy addition of parmesean, pepper flakes, and pepper/salt, per your taste. Good bar options for beverages/beer/happy hour drinks etc. Parking is a little dicey as you have to either park @ Mi Ranchito/Homer's, along 80th street, or maybe as "far" as down by Strang Hall. They do charge per topping (about .40) when ordering a slice OR a whole pie (more for the whole pizza), ends up (possibly) more than Minsky's for same 2, 3 or more toppings. Small side o' Ranch is an up-charge as well.

Melisa M.
Melisa M.

Great pizza! Got a slice of pizza for the first time here today. It was so good!! It is huge like bigger than your face. you get to pick your sauce and toppings. such a great size. service was really nice and fast. there's a drive thru window thing that you order from outside. it takes about 10 minutes. will be back!

Marissa S.
Marissa S.

Walked past here the other day, and just had to stop by. Loved the dining area with the massive open windows, it made for a relaxing, casual spot to be on such a sunny day. Ordered a couple beers, plus a slice of pizza, a side Caesar salad, and some wings. The pizza slice was GIANT, and the wing portion was more than filling, ended up with some leftover. Really enjoyed the NYC style pizza, not too thick, and a good balance of cheese and sauce! Our server was friendly, prompt, and even offered some Denver-made hot sauces to go with the slice - so good! Will definitely be back another sunny day.

Location

Welcome to Fat Sully's Pizza in Kansas City!

If you're a fan of New York style pizza and delicious comfort food, Fat Sully's Pizza is the perfect spot for you. Located at 4144 Pennsylvania Ave, this hip and casual joint offers a wide range of mouth-watering dishes for you to indulge in.

One of the standout features of Fat Sully's Pizza is their massive slices of pizza that are bigger than your face. Customers rave about the fresh and tasty toppings, along with the perfect balance of cheese and sauce. Whether you opt for classic pepperoni or create your own masterpiece, you're sure to be impressed by the quality and flavor of the pizza here.

But it's not just the pizza that steals the show at Fat Sully's. Customers also praise the parmesan garlic wings, the Nashville hot chicken biscuit, the Lola chicken in a biscuit with bacon and maple syrup, and the smash burgers. The menu offers a variety of options to cater to all tastes and preferences, ensuring that everyone leaves satisfied.

In addition to the delectable food, Fat Sully's Pizza provides a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere, complete with big screens showing sports, a full bar, and even some table games for entertainment. Whether you're out with friends for a casual meal or on a date night, Fat Sully's Pizza sets the perfect scene for a memorable dining experience.

Overall, the combination of delicious food, friendly service, and laid-back ambiance makes Fat Sully's Pizza a must-visit spot in Kansas City. So if you're craving a slice of authentic New York style pizza or looking to try some unique and tasty dishes, make sure to swing by Fat Sully's Pizza for a satisfying meal that will leave you coming back for more.